Throwback Thursday

25 years ago this month:

  • The Delaware Supreme Court publicly censured a part-time judge and suspended him for 3 months for (1) failing to pay federal, state, and city payroll taxes for his law firm’s employee payroll and to timely file withholding reports; (2) failing to pay property taxes and to pay some of his delinquent property taxes in accordance with a schedule he and the county had agreed on; (3) having 29 unpaid parking tickets; and (4) failing to properly maintain his law office books and records and incorrectly answering questions on the certificate of compliance with client account reconciliation requirements.  In the Matter of Williams, 701 A.2d 825 (Delaware 1997).
  • Accepting the recommendation of the Commission on Judicial Qualifications, the Florida Supreme Court publicly reprimanded a judge for, in her campaign mailers and newspaper advertisements, (1) claiming to have circuit judicial experience, when her service was that of a general master; (2) claiming that her opponent had no circuit judicial experience, when her opponent had extensive experience as a county judge who had been assigned to the circuit court; (3) injecting party politics into a non-partisan election by noting the party affiliation of the governor who had appointed her opponent as county judge; (4) including a photograph of her opponent sitting next to a criminal defendant, noting that her opponent “defend[ed] convicted mass murderer, cop killer, William Cruse,” when at the time of the photograph Cruse had not been convicted and her opponent was an assistant public defender; and (5) including a portion of a newspaper editorial implying that she, not her opponent, had been endorsed by the newspaper.  Inquiry Concerning Alley, 699 So. 2d 1369 (Florida 1997).
  • The Kansas Commission on Judicial Qualifications publicly admonished a judge for having a woman arrested for failing to appear for jury duty without holding a hearing, determining that she was in contempt, or imposing a sentence.  Inquiry Concerning Platt, Findings of fact, conclusions of law, and disposition (Kansas Commission on Judicial Qualifications October 27, 1997).
  • The Mississippi Supreme Court suspended a judge for 30 days without pay, publicly reprimanded her, and fined her $1,500 for (1) issuing an arrest warrant on petit larceny and simple assault charges filed by her friend and distant relative; (2) having license tags from her husband’s car on her car; (3) writing a check she did not have sufficient funds in her checking account to cover; and (4) failing to file reports of contributions or expenditures with the circuit clerk as required by statute.  Commission on Judicial Performance v. Franklin, 704 So. 2d 89 (Mississippi 1997).
  • Affirming the determination of the Commission on Judicial Discipline, the Nevada Supreme Court removed a judge from office for (1) borrowing money from court employees and not always promptly repaying the loans; (2) publicly endorsing and campaigning for a candidate for judicial office and testifying falsely to the Commission that, while going door-to-door campaigning for the candidate, he had only gone to houses where he knew the residents; (3) conducting a personal business from his judicial chambers, storing antiques throughout the courthouse and selling those antiques to persons with whom he came in contact at the courthouse; and directing city employees and jail trustees to move antiques into and out of the courthouse; (4) directing court employees during normal court business hours to go to his mother’s nursery business to provide Spanish translating services, to perform other personal errands for him, and to chauffeur him to and from his home for purposes including shopping for antiques; (5) directing or suggesting to persons appearing before the court who had been found guilty to contribute money to certain charities in lieu of paying fines to the city; and (6) using property he owned in part that was zoned for residential purposes for commercial purposes and causing his agents to trespass on the adjoining property to hook up water and sewer lines.  In the Matter of Davis, 946 P.2d 1033 (Nevada 1997).
  • Pursuant to an agreed statement of facts, the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct publicly censured a judge for a series of legal and procedural errors in a harassment case and making improper statements that compromised his impartiality and the proper administration of justice. In the Matter of Smith, Determination (New York Commission on Judicial Conduct October 29, 1997).
  • Accepting the findings and conclusions of the Board of Commissioners on Grievances and Discipline and adopting its recommendation, the Ohio Supreme Court publicly reprimanded a judge for appearing in a television commercial for a law firm. Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Allen, 684 N.E.2d 31 (Ohio 1997).
  • Adopting the recommendation of the Judicial Investigation Commission, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals publicly admonished a judge for creating the appearance that he had agreed to reduce the charges against an acquaintance and accepted gifts in exchange for the deal.  In the Matter of Reese, 495 S.E.2d 548 (West Virginia 1997).

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s